Oh my it’s been quite a while since I posted a recipe but I felt like this one needs to be shared. I had numerous sweet friends have babies this summer and what better way to convince them to let me come over and hold them by bringing a tray of my instant pot chicken enchiladas.
These enchiladas are super flavorful the first go around, and then get better with each passing day. I am pretty darn proud of this recipe and hope your family loves it as much as we do!
We earn commissions through our links. Please read the full disclosure for more info.
Instant Pot Chicken Enchiladas
To start off this recipe you will want to gather and prep all your ingredients.
Chop up a large red onion. Rinse 2 pounds of chicken thighs and set them aside. Rinse your cilantro and peel your garlic cloves.
Coat the bottom of the pot with 2 tbs of olive oil and add the red onion. Allow it to sauté for 3 minutes and stir occasionally.
While the onion is cooking, chop the cilantro. I use every bit of it including the stalks.
After 3 minutes and your onion is translucent, push cancel on the instant pot and add in the 2 pounds(ish) of chicken thighs, 1/2 cup of enchilada sauce (the trader joes brand is the only one I will use because it is the best!), chopped cilantro, 1/2 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp of freshly ground pepper, and press the garlic over the pot.
Give the mixture a quick stir to combine and then close the instant pot and turn the vent to seal.
Push the Meat/Stew button which should automatically set the pot to high pressure cook for 35 minutes. Once it finishes, push cancel and carefully open the vent to depressurize.
Your enchilada filling will be cooked and have a lot of liquid. To shred this up, you simply need to whip it with a fork. The meat will be so tender from the instant pot that this process will require little effort, which is why I love using an instant pot to make the filling for chicken enchiladas.
Look what just a minute of whipping will do! Next you are going to add 8 oz of shredded Mexican cheese and stir it in.
(This definitely isn’t one of my healthiest family dinners but it is dang delicious.)
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Farenheit.
Now you will fill each tortilla with the stuffing and lay them across an 8 x 13 baking pan or really whatever you have handy. The point is to get the tray full. Fold over the sides of the tortilla like a taco and flip them over so the folded side is down.
There is no magic here to make the stuffing distribute perfectly between all the enchiladas. You may have a bit extra filling leftover and have to open up some of the enchiladas that you have already laid down. Just play around with it until you are able to use all the filling.
There will be a little bit of liquid left over in the instant pot which you can either dump on top or discard.
Cover your enchiladas with the remainder of the enchilada sauce and use another 8 oz bag of shredded Mexican cheese to top it off.
Bake at 350 degrees uncovered for 30 minutes.
This is a perfect meal to make ahead and leave unbaked to bring to functions. You can just quickly heat it up and people will likely think you are a culinary genius!
You could even make this ahead of time and freeze it so that you have an easy dinner during the first few weeks home with a new baby!
It pairs well with my homemade salsa recipe! The best part is these instant pot chicken enchiladas are toddler-approved!